Setophaga palmarum palmarum
Status: Uncommon regular spring migrant east and central, rare casual west. Rare regular fall migrant east and east-central, rare casual elsewhere.
Documentation: Specimen: palmarum: UNSM ZM12018, 8 May 1917 Lancaster Co.
Taxonomy: Two well-defined subspecies occur (Pyle 1997, Wilson 2013): palmarum, breeding from Mackenzie east through northern Saskatchewan and northern Manitoba to north-central Ontario (James Bay) and south to the US, and hypochrysea, breeding in the eastern part of the species’ breeding range from eastern Ontario through central and southern Quebec to Labrador and Newfoundland and south to New York and Nova Scotia.
The expected subspecies in Nebraska is the western subspecies palmarum. Despite its eastern Canada breeding range and fall migration east of the Appalachians (Wilson 2013), there are a few Nebraska reports of eastern hypochrysea. These are discussed under Comments.
Spring: Apr 14,15,16 <<<>>> May 29,30 Jun 2
Reports are from mid-Apr through May, although there are earlier reports 19 Mar 2000 in Buffalo Co (Jorgensen 2002), 26 Mar 1950 Antelope Co, 5 Apr 1972 Hall Co, and 5 Apr 1992 Sarpy Co (Grzybowski 1992).
There are several Panhandle reports: 29 Apr 2009 Dawes Co, 23 May 1980 Sheridan Co (Rosche 1982), 5 May 1984 Sheridan Co (Williams 1984), 5 May 1994 Dawes Co, 3-4 on 5 May 1996 in Dawes Co (Grzybowski 1996), 7 May 1993 Sheridan Co (Grzybowski 1993), 8 May 1992 Sheridan Co (Grzybowski 1992), three on 11 May 1996 in Sheridan Co (Grzybowski 1996), 13 May 2010 Box Butte Reservoir, Dawes Co, 14 May 2003 Clear Creek WMA, Garden Co, 24 May 1962 Dawes Co, and 30 May 2011 Bushnell Cemetery, Kimball Co.
- High counts: 26 in Sarpy Co 11 May 1996, including 10 at Wehrspann Lake, 7 at Holmes Lake, Lancaster Co 4 May 2018, 7 at Memphis Lakes SRA, Saunders Co 5 May 2018, and 7 at Marsh Wren Community Wetlands, Lancaster Co 3 May 2019.
- There were 143 reported in 2018, 46 in spring 1999, and 41 in spring 2013.
Fall: Aug 26,30, Sep 1 <<<>>> Oct 17,20,20
There is an earlier report 19 Aug 2013 Sioux Co, and later reports 24 Oct 2013 Lancaster Co, 30 Oct 1988 Washington Co, 6 Nov 2008 Gering, Scotts Bluff Co, 10 Nov 1966 Douglas-Sarpy Cos, and one videographed in Keith Co 11 Nov 2017. One was extremely late for the location on the Calamus-Loup CBC 27 Dec 2002, and apparently the same bird was seen by different observers at Chalco Hills RA, Sarpy Co 20 and 22 Dec 2017.
Both subspecies migrate southeastward in fall (Wilson 2013) and are rare in the Interior, although an unexpected influx in 2015, reflected by no less than seven reports of single birds, most with good details, was very unusual; a similar influx, with eight reports, occurred in 2012, six were reported in 2016, and 8 in 2017.
Panhandle reports are few: 19 Aug 2013 Sioux Co, 14 Sep 2016 Chadron SP, Dawes Co, 18 Sep 2013 Sioux Co, 20 Sep 2013 Sheridan Co, 23 and 29 September 1979 Dawes Co (Rosche 1982), 23 Sep 2012 Scotts Bluff Co, 28 Sep 1996 Sheridan Co (Grzybowski 1997), 1 Oct 1988 Sheridan Co (Grzybowski 1989), 6 Oct 2018 Dawes Co (banded, photo), and 8 Oct 1994 Sheridan Co.
Comments: Eastern hypochrysea is not expected in Nebraska, nor are intergrades of the two subspecies; intergrades are rare, as the subspecies have only a narrow zone of overlap in their respective breeding ranges and migration routes and timing differ; hypochrysea migrates in the eastern US, while migration of palmarum extends west to central Nebraska (Wilson 2013, Pittaway 1995). Hypochrysea has been identified as far west as California (Louis Bevier, pers. comm.), but reports on the Great Plains and westward are not expected.
On occasion palmarum can appear quite yellow, but almost always shows some whitish coloration on the underparts between the breast and undertail coverts, whereas hypochrysea has completely yellow underparts, requiring a good photo or view of the bird to determine subspecies in the field. There are no documented occurrences of hypochrysea in Nebraska, although there are several reports of varying credibility, the following two being the most suggestive. One photographed at Fontenelle Forest, Sarpy Co 11 May 1986 was thought to be likely hypochrysea based on thick reddish flank streaks and extensively yellow underparts (Phil Swanson, personal communication). Subspecies hypochrysea migrates earlier than palmarum, lending some support to the very early Buffalo Co record listed under Spring.
There are these additional Nebraska reports, most by experienced observers, suggestive of hypochrysea: two were at Branched Oak Lake, Lancaster Co 27 Apr 1997, one was in southeast Otoe Co 2 May 1999, a group of seven (“all very yellow”) was in Dixon Co 2 May 1999, one was reported without details as an “eastern” in Hall Co 10 May 1997, one was in Seward Co 10 May 2015, and one with “yellow breast” was at Neale Woods, Douglas Co 17 May 2014.
Fall identification of hypochrysea is complicated by the presence of palmarum with increased yellow coverage of the mid-underparts (Dunn and Garrett 1977). Hypochrysea migrates later than palmarum in fall (Wilson 2013), lending credibility to the Washington Co report below. A hypochrysea was photographed in Broomfield Co, Colorado as late as 18 Nov 2016 (eBird.org, accessed November 2017). However, another late bird, video-graphed near Lemoyne, Keith County, on the late date of 11 Nov 2017 was palmarum, indicating both subspecies may occur late in the season. Nebraska reports, most by experienced observers, are of one “yellowish” at Harlan Co Reservoir, Harlan Co 20 Sep 2001, one “very yellow” in Otoe Co 23 Sep 2000, one with “obvious yellowish underparts” 30 Oct 1988 in Washington Co, and one in Gering, Scotts Bluff Co 6 Nov 2008.
CBC: Christmas Bird Count
UNSM: University of Nebraska State Museum
WMA: Wildlife Management Area (State)
Dunn, J.L., and K.L. Garrett. 1997. A field guide to warblers of North America. Houghton Mifflin Company, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Grzybowski, J.A. 1989. Southern Great Plains Region. American Birds 43: 124-126.
Grzybowski, J.A. 1992. Southern Great Plains Region. American Birds 46: 443-446.
Grzybowski, J.A. 1993. Southern Great Plains Region. American Birds 47: 426-429.
Grzybowski, J.A. 1996. Southern Great Plains Region. Field Notes 50: 296-300.
Grzybowski, J.A. 1997. Southern Great Plains Region. Field Notes 51: 78-82.
Jorgensen, J.G. 2002. 2002 (sic; =2000). (12th) Report of the NOU Records Committee. NBR 70: 84-90.
Pittaway, R. 1995. Ontario Birds 13: 23-27.
Pyle, P. 1997. Identification Guide to North American Birds. Part I, Columbidae to Ploceidae. Slate Creek Press, Bolinas, California, USA.
Rosche, R.C. 1982. Birds of northwestern Nebraska and southwestern South Dakota, an annotated checklist. Cottonwood Press, Crawford, Nebraska, USA.
Williams, F. 1984. Southern Great Plains Region. American Birds 38: 929-931.
Wilson Jr., W.H. 2013. Palm Warbler (Setophaga palmarum), version 2.0. In The Birds of North America Poole, Editor). Cornell Lab of Ornithology, Ithaca, New York, USA. https://doi.org/10.2173/bna.238.
Silcock, W.R., and J.G. Jorgensen. 2018. Palm Warbler (Setophaga palmarum), Version 1.0. In Birds of Nebraska — Online. www.BirdsofNebraska.org